144+ Golf Villas, Golf Cabins, Golf Hotels, Golf Resort Rentals, and other Private Golf Retreats in Shelter Island |
  1. USA
  2. New York
  3. Shelter Island

Explore Shelter Island Golf Retreats

About Shelter Island Vacation Rentals

Explore over 144 golf accommodation rentals in Shelter Island. From luxurious golf villas to cozy golf cabins, golf resorts, and exclusive golf hotels, each offers premium amenities designed for families, groups, and golf enthusiasts. Enjoy exceptional comfort and a one-of-a-kind golf experience with these incredible accommodations. Perfect for tranquil golf escapes, relaxing retreats, or golf-inspired getaways, these properties provide style and comfort in Shelter Island.

Looking for last-minute deals or the best offers on golf villas, golf cabins, golf resorts, and other golf retreats? StayAndPlay makes it easy to compare options in Shelter Island. Choose from spacious family-friendly stays, charming golf escapes, or luxurious golf retreats tailored for ultimate relaxation and play.

Find spacious family-friendly golf accommodations, golf cottage, or luxurious golf villas—all designed for maximum comfort and convenience during your visit.

On average, golf accommodation rentals in Shelter Island offer approximately 916.51 ft² of space, giving you and your group plenty of room to relax and enjoy the stunning golf course surroundings.

The average nightly rate for golf accommodation rentals in Shelter Island typically ranges around US $1,044.

StayAndPlay offers a secure and convenient platform to compare and book the best golf retreats in Shelter Island. Explore a wide range of properties at unbeatable rates, and enjoy a unique stay immersed in golf with us.

Show more
Show less

Top Golf Accommodation Types in Shelter Island

Type Count
Vacation Homes 116
Holiday Apartments 4
Others 4
Cottages 3
B&B 2

Use these Quick Filters to Find a Vacation Rental in Shelter Island

★ Pro Tip: StayAndPlay simplifies your search for the best golf accommodations from leading vacation rental OTAs like Booking.com and more. Use our Advanced Filter to explore golf villas, cozy golf cabins, golf hotels, and golf resorts. Filter by availability, pricing, cancellation options, and amenities to discover the ideal golf retreat in Shelter Island.

Weather in Shelter Island, NY

View the weather forecast for Shelter Island before booking your Shelter Island Vacation Rentals to confirm your best time to go.

December - February
High 60°F       Low 26°F
March - May
High 77°F       Low 40°F
June - August
High 91°F       Low 64°F
September - November
High 84°F       Low 38°F

Activities Shelter Island Guest Reviews Local Attractions

StayAndPlay offers a diverse selection of the top golf villas, golf hotels, and other golf retreats around the world. Shelter Island Guest Reviews Find the Best Golf Experiences & Activities for Your Golf Trip


Mashomack Preserve
Shelter Island Kayak
Wades Beach
Sylvester Manor
Havens House
Shelter Island Historical Society
Cooper's Beach
East Hampton Main Beach
Wolffer Estates Vineyard
Hammonasset Beach State Park
Meschutt Beach
Guild Hall
Ditch Plains Beach
Hither Hills State Park
Clinton Crossing Premium Outlets
The Hamptons Beaches
Orient Beach State Park
Bay Street Theatre
Indian Wells Beach
Ponquogue Beach

Find Nearby Cabin Rentals in these Cities & Neighborhoods


Sylvester Manor 363 Properties
Shelter Island Kayak 305 Properties
Shelter Island Historical Society 222 Properties
Havens House 219 Properties
Menantic Creek 213 Properties
Shorewood 182 Properties
Wades Beach 178 Properties
Mashomack Preserve 174 Properties
Shelter Island Heights 101 Properties

Frequently Asked Questions About Shelter Island?

What are the best golf resorts, luxury villas, and vacation rentals in Shelter Island?

Looking for a place to stay in Shelter Island? Explore these highly-rated golf vacation rentals for a one-of-a-kind golf retreat, where you can relax, unwind, and get ready to play your best game:

How many golf stays with private pools are available in Shelter Island?

Find exceptional golf retreats with private pools near Shelter Island on StayAndPlay. Relax in serene golf vacation rentals with exclusive pool access and picturesque golf course views. Whether it's a spacious golf villa or a secluded golf cabin, these properties offer the perfect blend of luxury and relaxation, so you can focus on your game.

What are the top-rated golf retreats in Shelter Island for family stays?

Searching for a family-friendly golf retreat in Shelter Island? Explore these top-rated options, each loved by families and groups who have stayed in Shelter Island:

How many StayAndPlay golf vacation rentals are available in Shelter Island?

StayAndPlay, as of 2025, features over 144 unique golf villas, golf hotels, golf resorts, and more in Shelter Island. Choose from eco-friendly golf accommodations, golf hotels and golf resorts, with new options added frequently.

By 2025, StayAndPlay has curated over 144 stunning properties in Shelter Island, sourced from trusted platforms. Plan your next golf trip now.

For 2025, StayAndPlay provides access to over 144 premier golf accommodations in Shelter Island. Find your ideal golf-retreat and play your best game with StayAndPlay.

Nearby Neighborhood (5) 
Neighborhood Property Count
The Heights Golf Rental Cottages and Golf Getaways in Shelter Island, New York 419
Menantic Creek Golf Rental Cottages and Golf Getaways in Shelter Island, New York 213
Coecles Harbor Golf Rental Cottages and Golf Getaways in Shelter Island, New York 293
Shorewood Golf Rental Cottages and Golf Getaways in Shelter Island, New York 182
Montclair Colony Golf Rental Cottages and Golf Getaways in Shelter Island, New York 197

People Also Ask

There are 14 hotels in Shelter Island and 120 rentals

Recently Booked Private Villas, Cabin Resorts, and Rentals Shelter Island