1. USA
  2. New York
  3. Shelter Island
  4. Cabin Rentals

Shelter Island World-Class Golf Experiences: Exclusive Golf Villas & Retreats

Find the best cabins in Shelter Island - We found 146 exact matches

About Shelter Island Cabin Rentals on StayAndPlay

Are you searching for a cabin rental, resorts and outdoor private villas for your next vacation to Shelter Island ? StayAndPlay has plenty of accommodations and short-term rentals to match your needs. We offer a broad selection of cabin rentals, cottages, resorts, villas and private homes perfect for outdoor-seeking travelers who crave some time away from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Whether it's a secluded cabin in the woods or an outdoor villa surrounded by lush greenery, we can help you find the perfect spot for your getaway.

Enjoy breathtaking views from outside decks, balconies or patios in Shelter Island with plenty of space for you. And with our range of cabin rental options, there's something for every budget—from luxury cabins to more affordable ones.

Spend some quality time together with your loved ones, take a dip in the pool or wade in the nearby lake. Relax in stylish suites featuring tasteful decor and modern amenities like flat-screen TVs and fully-stocked mini bars - pamper yourself after a long day outdoors! Or perhaps take advantage of on-site spa services such as massage therapies and body treatments – nothing beats having all this convenience just steps away from your door!

Last minute travel or need to book a place during a quarantine? You can find a place to stay in Shelter Island by using StayAndPlay our last-minute cabin rental deals. Simply enter your trip date, and use our filter option to select by price, accommodation types, amenities, or rating. StayAndPlay makes your booking hassle-free. Stay Close to Nature with StayAndPlay.

Show more
Show less

Frequently Asked Questions About Shelter Island Rental Cabins

There are a lot of options in Shelter Island. If you plan on staying in the Shelter Island area, consider making a reservation for a few nights at one of these properties as these have been rated the top Cabin Rentals in Shelter Island:

The average cost of renting a cabin in Shelter Island per night is $1,043. This cost includes the entire cabin as well as all amenities attached to it. Based on stats, families, or groups of travelers spend an average of per night in the cabin, when vacationing in Shelter Island, and this brings the average total of $1,043 for each cabin. You should also note that this price varies with seasons, so make sure to confirm the actual price before making your budget list.
Spotting the best rental cabins in Shelter Island is not too difficult. All you need to do is to check the amenities listed on the property or sort the list to see the top-rated cabins. This can include hot tubs, private swimming pools, large sitting rooms, washing machines, etc. If you’re coming in a group, another thing to watch for is the number of rooms the cabin has.
Yes. We have high-standard cabins in Shelter Island that allow pets.
Most of our rentals are suitable for families. Check out the complete list of cabins in Shelter Island to find what works for you.
There are 146 cabins in Shelter Island that have a swimming pool, which may include private indoor swimming pools.
There are 146 cabins in Shelter Island that have hot tubs.
Yes, there are many luxury cabins in Shelter Island. Find out more rental cabins Shelter Island with all the best amenities for your vacation rental.